swissmarg (
swissmarg) wrote in
hp_diversity2014-11-21 02:49 pm
Entry tags:
A Question of Character: Blaise

A couple of community members suggested that one reason why people may hesitate to write about characters of color is that they don't have a good handle on those characters' backgrounds, personalities, and experiences, either because the characters are not sufficiently fleshed out in the books, or because the writers don't feel confident writing outside of their own ethnicity/culture due to a lack of familiarity.
In response to that, I'm launching an occasional series of Character Discussions. The idea is to get to know these characters better, to share ideas and speculation, to ask questions, and to spark people's imagination.
I thought we could start off with Blaise Zabini, for no particular reason. :)
The Harry Potter Wiki entry on Blaise contains a good summary of what's known about the character, as well as some speculation based on those facts.
Here are some possible ideas to get the discussion started:
- Where do his ancestors come from? How long has his family been in Britain?
- Why was he sorted into Slytherin?
- What career do you think he went into after Hogwarts and why?
- Do you agree with the Wiki entry, which claims Blaise was arrogant, disdainful, confrontational, contemptuous, disrespectful, and difficult to please romantically?
- What do you think his name reveals about him, if anything?
Feel free to ask your own questions as well, and to make any additional remarks you'd like about Blaise Zabini!

no subject
no subject
no subject
Looking at the Zabini surnames on Ancestry (a genealogy website), they are mostly from Italy, but I also found a Mohammad Zabini. I could see Zabini being a transliteration of an Arabic name too.
I just found this post by sistermagpie on DW with a really interesting discussion in the comments about Blaise's origins and the possibilities of Italian vs. Arab vs. some mixture.
no subject
PS--Ah, yep! A very short and almost embarrassing - compared to other countries - colonial history! My grandfather lived in East Africa for 30 years! :) xx
no subject
Italy's colonial history is extremely brief, and it was a total fiasco too. But apparently the people of the countries that we invaded were very fond of the Italians, thinking us as nice and good-natured. My grandfather owned some houses in Somalia and Eritrea, but he never talked of Italians and local people mixing. That said, there is an Italian extremely old song called "Faccetta Nera" (lit. "Little Black Face"), about some cute black girl the soldiers had encountered in East Africa. But I'm not sure Italians would pass on their surnames to the children born from unions with the locals (I've seen the same thing in Angola three years ago, there were some people with mixed heritage, but they didn't have their fathers' names they said - but of course, Angola and Portugal's history is yet different, because they do have Portuguese names in Angola).
A Mohammad Zabini would make totally sense to me. It is a surname from the south of Italy and that's where the highest concentration of Arabs was in the past, therefore an Arab changing his surname to fit in would totally make sense to me. Of course though, we are talking about something that happened between the VII and the XI century, therefore I think that by now they would have lost all the blackness (I have no clue how to phrase this!) that they might have had.
That discussion is very interesting. OMG. I loved that bit about "Cho Chang", but to be fair with J.K. Rowling "Chang" is in third place as one of the most common surnames, and believe me when I say that those 10 surnames are everywhere. I studied Chinese and went to China twice, studied there and I have many Chinese friends and had many Chinese teachers and they were all called "Jiang", "Chen", "Li", "Zhang", etc. They just are. Okay, wrong character for this discussion though, sorry for that!
I also found some statistics about the surname Zabini in Italy:
Percentage: 0.00046%
Number of people sharing this surname in Italy: 276
It's really not that common. x
no subject
Though, because his mother had what, seven husbands there certainly is a possibility he took someone else's name. And I, too, wouldn't have him speaking fluent Italian because to me he's English.
no subject
no subject
Three reasons. 1. He is described as dark skinned in the books, and therefore I thought that since he is not "light brown" or "brown" or any colour that could be seen as mixed, both parents must have been black. 2. The actor they cast for the films. He doesn't look mixed to me, and even if I don't really consider films as canon, I just thought that since they've cast him, they must have known something for sure. 3. My personal experience. All of my black friends from England have both parents who are black. I by no means know everybody in England, but all my of black friends came from black families, therefore I just thought it natural for Blaise to have both parents coming from the same background. But if nobody shares this idea of Blaise then it must be something that I came up with on my own and thought it was canon.
Urgh, no no no! No Italian for him! And most of the times he is like, "(In Italian)What when button rabbit gooogooo pheasant." And Hermione (Pansy, Draco, Ginny...) is like, "What?" and I'm like, "WTF" too.. Alright, this is mean, my English is not perfect either - especially not tonight - but they can contact someone Italian to beta a sentence. I'd volunteer.. And Blaise is British to me too. x
no subject
Regarding the actor, the women who play the Patil twins are from Bangladesh and while that last name is very common, it's most often found in the part of India that's further central/west (see here) so I don't think that's necessarily indicative of anything just because the actor may or may not have a particular origin (though I personally couldn't find where it said what his origin might be besides British).
I just find it very strange you are so adamant that he's not at all Italian when his name indicates that he is. If I met a person named Rossi or Marino it would be my first assumption until I was told otherwise. Also, my own half-brother has a very Norwegian-American name but his mother is from Peru so he does not look like a Scandinavian in any way. He's not even what one would consider black (Hispanic really) but he is what I would call dark-skinned.
ETA: Though I do still see Blaise as primarily black and English, the idea that he can't be Italian because of those factors led me to research some well-known mixed race Italians.
Sara Gama female soccer player born in Trieste, Italian mother, father is from Congo; Carlton Myers Italian/British citizenship, basketball player, carried the flag for Italy at the Sydney Olympics, father is from Saint Vincent and Grenadine and mother from Pesaro; Salvatore Marino actor with Italian father and Eritrean mother; Elisa Sednaoui model, actress, director, born in Piedmont to Egyptian father and Italian mother; Matteo Ferrari soccer player, Italian father, mother from Guinea, girlfriend from Venezuela; Fabio Liverani soccer player born in Rome to Italian father, Somali mother; and Stephan El Shaarawy soccer player, born in Savona to an Italian mother and an Egyptian father. These are just the people I could find in about two hours of poking around on the internet. Surely there are many more such people who aren't famous.
no subject
But I was still talking about Blaise being of black descendent because of my head canon. If he is mixed, by all means, I see no problems in that happening. (And I also think that Alisanne has a very good point with that Muggle vs Wizarding world.) Also his father might have been adopted, like Balotelli! And maybe he was a Quidditch player! Now I have a new head canon forming in my head! Lol! Quidditch players are wealthy I think, that would have attracted Mrs Zabini. I see a plot bunny forming in my head..
And as I said, I'm just annoyed with people butchering my language for the sole purpose of adding an exotic feeling to their stories. Blaise is British to me, and the last thing that usually Italians pass on to their children for more than a generation when they are abroad is the language (unless they have to communicate with their grandparents).
But yes, that's just my point of view, and I'm glad we had this exchange so that I can see that it was just in my head to consider canon to have both his parents black. Xxx
no subject
Of course, with so little canon there's nothing wrong with making it up for yourself. Just, personally I see nothing unrealistic about Blaise having some Italian ancestry while still identifying as black and being seen by others as black. It doesn't have to be the most common situation for it to be within the realm of possibility.
no subject
Probably thinking that both his parents are black must be my head canon then, if it's not shared by people out there. I just took it for granted. And I thought about it, and I think that I know why I think that (can you tell that I am knackered after having been out all day and walking for kilometres in Milan? I can't phrase, is this even correct?).
Three reasons. 1. He is described as dark skinned in the books, and therefore I thought that since he is not "light brown" or "brown" or any colour that could be seen as mixed, both parents must have been black. 2. The actor they cast for the films. He doesn't look mixed to me, and even if I don't really consider films as canon, I just thought that since they've cast him, they must have known something for sure. 3. My personal experience. All of my black friends from England have both parents who are black. I by no means know everybody in England, but all my of black friends came from black families, therefore I just thought it natural for Blaise to have both parents coming from the same background. But if nobody shares this idea of Blaise then it must be something that I came up with on my own and thought it was canon.
I don't think that the Italian ancestor would be a realistic solution though, because in Italy we have a very different history than the U.S. and black and white didn't really mix in the past - there were not that many black people here in the past actually: we didn't have that many colonies, nor we imported slaves - and I just don't see it as a realistic solution. Also, I don't think that if a white man would have had a child with a black woman he would have wanted to pass on his surname. But everything is possible, I just don't think it's very probable.
But yes, I am more peeved by the way some authors write his "Italian dialogues" where I cannot understand anything at all. To me he is very British.. (My friend from England was teaching me Cockney the other day, I cannot see her as anything but British.) x
no subject
no subject
- What do you think his name reveals about him, if anything?
Not a lot. It suggests an Italian background, but we don't know if that comes from being born there. It could be the name of an Italian father who lived in Britain. It could be the name of one of his mother's other husbands. It could be his mother's family name for that matter -- people assume she's black because of the likelihood that an Italian father called Zabini was white, but as far as I recall from what's actually said in canon it could easily be the other way round?
- Where do his ancestors come from? How long has his family been in Britain?
Again, nothing much to go on here. He's described as "black" which in British terms usually means specifically African or West Indian ancestry. He's also described as having "long slanting eyes" which sounds like it's meant to be a hint at some East Asian ancestry. He talks like a posh Englishman, or at least does not talk with any kind of flagged regional or foreign accent in the way Hagrid or Fleur or Dean do. You could read that many different ways.
- Why was he sorted into Slytherin?
That's easy enough: he clearly seems to be a pureblood bigot.
- What career do you think he went into after Hogwarts and why?
Since he's presumably very rich, maybe none -- just a gentleman of leisure like Lucius Malfoy was. Politics would be another likely choice.
- Do you agree with the Wiki entry, which claims Blaise was arrogant, disdainful, confrontational, contemptuous, disrespectful, and difficult to please romantically?
Arrogant, disdainful, contemptuous? Yes, clearly. Supercilious aristocrat to a T.
Confrontational? Not particularly. He falls on Goyle when Harry lets go of the door and gets into a row with him because of that, but that's not surprising. He also expresses scepticism about Draco bigging himself up mysteriously, which is also reasonable (although actually he's mistaken about that). Mostly he seems disdainful, which is almost an opposite of confrontational.
Disrepectful? Of what or who? WTF does that even mean here?
Difficult to please romantically? Presumably based solely on Pansy's arch comment when she mentions that he thinks Ginny is good-looking, which he coldly rebuffs with a comment about her blood traitorliness. Might be a hint that he's gay and therefore not interested in girls anyway. Might be a hint that he really does have a big crush on Ginny and doesn't want Pansy the motormouth to know (a la Snape and Lily). Might not!
no subject
Because that's near the beginning of HBP, which is not very long after the end of OotP where we see Snape call Lily mudblood (but before we know quite how much that really meant) I could easily believe that yes, we're meant to draw that parallel that Blaise does find Ginny attractive and doesn't want anyone to know and uses that kind of language to deny it.
no subject
I assume Blaise was Sorted into Slytherin because he's ambitious. Yes, he's a pureblood bigot, too, and we assume all of them go to Slytherin, but I suspect that if a Slytherin at heart thought another House would help them more, they'd try to Sort there.
My head canon for Blaise sees him being contrite and apologetic after the war, so I have written him as a teacher and as a lawyer. I imagine he'd more likely be a member of the idle rich, like Draco, however. I could also see him in politics, I suppose. And now I want to write (or read) Blaise Zabini, badass Auror fic. *g*
I'm not sure where they got the "difficult to please romantically" bit from. All we see is him dismissing Pansy's assertion that he thinks Ginny Weasley is attractive, and he could have had many reasons for doing that. I wouldn't want Pansy knowing my business either. :P
Arrogant and contemptuous? Totally. But again, I like to see characters progress beyond canon, and I like to think he got over that after the war (or at least learned to hide it better).
no subject
Uhm, yessss! :D Lol Blaise as an Auror! That would be so interesting. I wonder how he'd handle all the cases and the people. Omg so much potential for humour there.
Now I actually just want to go back and re-read all his canon appearances to get a better handle on his characterization -- although I do have some fully formed feelings about him, it's always fun to find new subtleties. And I read him sooo long ago...
no subject
I point this out, not to whitewash Blaise's ethnicity. I just see it as somewhat likely with an Italian last name that he's got a bit of both.
As the Wiki article mentions, Blaise was invited to Slughorn's group which does suggest there is something about him worth pursuing.
I don't see that one remark about Ginny should indicate basically anything about him romantically. It's one offensive remark, likely said as much to deflect as anything.
I am not sure we really see enough of him to pin him with that bevy of negative descriptors though I have always sort of seen him as being a lot like Draco when he's being a proper pureblood Malfoy--well-mannered and snooty.
When writing fanfic I think he makes a great Slytherin to use when you want someone who didn't get their hands too dirty (like Crabbe and Goyle).
no subject
- Where do his ancestors come from? How long has his family been in Britain?
I agree with him being of mixed ethnicity. And tbh, I don't care if his father was Italien or not and if he has parents of colour. I can see him easily speak Italian and English and other languages too because he seems to be very clever and I always thought his mother dragged him with her throught the world and her marriages before he went to Hogwards. Not the easiest childhood, I think.
- Why was he sorted into Slytherin?
He's intelligent, good at sheeming (learned from the best) and a man for himself.
- What career do you think he went into after Hogwarts and why?
I have no clue, but I totally love fics where he is a bon viveur or took an unusual career path like being partner with Neville...
- Do you agree with the Wiki entry, which claims Blaise was arrogant, disdainful, confrontational, contemptuous, disrespectful, and difficult to please romantically?
arrogant - yes,
disdainful - yes,
confrontational - not really (he sneers and snarks but wouldn't fight),
difficult to please romantically - I have no clue, his comment about Ginny could be everything, a hint that he likes her, a hint that he doesn't like women at all, he hint that he is an arse. Too little evidence in canon for a verdict.
- What do you think his name reveals about him, if anything?
I always thought that his name and charakter fits more the old Greek basilios which means something like regal, than coming from blaesus which means to lips. One wouldn't make fun of him in canon, would you?
no subject
This is a really good point. It's been several years since the books were published, and in that time lots of fics have been written about Blaise -- so much so that we now have the situation of having more fanon material on him than canon material. I think it's true that fics tend to 'feed' off each other and develop a characterization that is slightly to completely different than the canon. (This has happened with other characters too, of course.)
I would like to know whether people think this is a valid thing to happen? Or should writers and artists return more often - and more strictly - to the source material for their inspiration?
no subject
no subject
I was just saying to
It's so funny how different our perceptions can be. :)
no subject
no subject
no subject
no subject
That being said, I do also love his fanon persona as well. It's such an opposite persona from the books, as his fanon self tends to be Draco's even-headed bff who is quick to make friends with the Trio and who often pulls Draco in with them -- at least in lots of H/D fanfiction. As such, Blaise can be pretty fun to play with and I think that's why he's so often portrayed in fics, along with Pansy, as Draco's best friend and past Hogwarts roommate. (I mean the roommate thing might not be fanon, I don't remember how Slytherin dorms are laid out or if they are even mentioned in much detail)
As for why he was sorted into Slytherin.... hmm. It's possibly because he holds himself in such high regard that he is essentially his own first priority. Or that he exhibits the traditional Slytherin qualities of cunningness, ambition, traditionalism, etc etc. I guess this one is up to personal headcanon.
no subject
I think the thing with fanon and canon is we actually have room to make someone like Blaise more three dimensional. What we see in canon is just one facet.
no subject
no subject
no subject
He's also not ostracized, he just has his own agenda.
That does feel very much like how I picture Blaise, too. I tend to think he considers himself above everyone, and Draco's group is included in that. But he isn't ostracized at all, I don't think.
no subject
From 1943 to '45, US soldiers fought in Italy during WW II. An African-American soldier (who just happened to be a wizard) had a child with an Italian witch named Zabini (latest possible year of birth 1944). Given the social standing of black soldiers at the time, I'm assuming it was a consensual relationship, even though it may not necessarily have resulted in marriage ... and if it did, said soldier either took his wife's name, or they got divorced later, he left the child with her and she went back to her maiden name for herself and her baby.
That child (male, to retain the name) emigrates to the UK after the war (possible, especially in light of the slowly gaining-in-importance of the predecessor of today's European Union) and marries a Briton. He'd be in his mid-thirties by 1979/80, when Blaise was born, and Mrs Zabini may well have been dark-skinned again (after all, we never learn of HER ethnicity).
Using this construct, Blaise may be three-quarters black and still have Italian ancestry (even though he'd most likely identify himself as British).
Far-fetched maybe, but I think at least somewhat plausible. :)
no subject
no subject
I was one of those who made the point that the characters' backgrounds really need to be beefed up in order to give the characters the dynamic energy that would allow them energize an entire story.
Kudos for asking about his name and seeing the link to his ancestry.
There have been some really good questions but lets broaden the canvas shall we?
While it's great to look at Italy's limited colonial past or even WW II, remember that:
1. Italy is not that far from the African continent.
2. Genetic research shows that admixture between Mediterranean Europeans and Africans has been going on for millenia most likely due to the proximity.
3. Italy was the center of the Roman Empire which stretched (I know I'm going to get this wrong, apologies in advance) from the outer reaches of Eastern Europe all the way to England.
4. Rome fought a war with Carthage, an African nation and its rival and then took control of Egypt (which sits on the African continent) and I think Libya, creating the African province.
Conclusion: Admixture between Italians and Africans has been happening for millenia. It is not that big of a stretch to see Blaise having an Italian name. (Don't stop at WW II. Remember, before WW I toppled it, the Austro-Hungarian Empire took in a lot of territory and nationalities - again, admixture).
But I'm not totally convinced the name Zabini IS Italian. It could be something else. I tend to think if it's not Italian, it's Eastern European which brings in Hungary and Romania, etc. I could be wrong. But it's worth investigating.
Why does Blaise have a French first name? Some of you have mentioned that maybe Rowling was making a play on the word "blase" or "blaze". Fair enough. But when I see Blaise, I think Blaise Pascal, whom I was taught was a pioneer in computer science (the Pascal programming language was named for him although I doubt anyone uses it anymore).
These questions everyone has come up with are fantastic. I just wanted throw in a reminder that history goes WAY back. Don't cheat yourself of the resources that are out there.
Also remember the impact of geography and how the old empires - Roman, Ottoman Turk, Russian, Austro-Hungarian, British, Spanish - mixed cultures across time and place for millenia.
Okay that was enough self-righteousness from me for one night. =^) But I just wanted to toss out that flag about remembering how deep and long history goes.
And I haven't even touched on the power of mining mythology and using the archetypes.